Jamie was an All-Ivy League shortstop at the University of Pennsylvania, where she still holds Top 10 All-time records in batting average, hitting streak, RBI/YR, and Hits/YR, despite only playing a freshman season. In high school, Jamie led The Peddie School to four consecutive Prep A State Championships, and was chosen First Team All-State Prep four times and First Team All-Area three times. She was also named the Trenton Times and Trentonian area Player of the Year in 2008. Her 2005-2008 Peddie softball teams will be inducted into the Peddie Sports Hall of Fame in 2023. In her 18U travel season she participated in the ASA Gold National Tournament in Oklahoma City with the Nightmare Gold.

Jamie has kept softball in her adult life by playing co-ed slowpitch with her husband, Matt, who was an Academic All-American baseball player at Stevens Institute of Technology. She also assisted in coaching the 14u Witches Futures for two seasons, and looks forward to someday coaching her own two kids, Mia and Trey, as well.